Appendectomy by Pediatric Surgeons in North Carolina is Associated With Higher Charge Than General Surgeons

Abstract

IntroductionThe delivery of pediatric surgical care for acute appendicitis involves general surgeons (GS) and pediatric surgeons (PS), but the differences in clinical practice are primarily undescribed. We examined charge differences between GS and PS for the treatment of pediatric acute appendicitis. MethodsWe performed a retrospective review of the North Carolina hospital discharge database (2013-2017) in pediatric patients (≤18 y) who had surgery for appendiceal pathology (acute or chronic appendicitis and other appendiceal pathology). We performed a bivariate analysis of surgical charges over the type of surgical providers (GS, PS, other specialty, and unassigned surgeons). ResultsOver the study period, 21,049 patients had appendicitis or other diseases of the appendix, and 15,230 (72.4%) underwent appendectomy. Patients who were operated on by PS were younger (10 y, interquartile range (IQR): 6-13 versus 13 y, IQR: 9-16, P < 0.001). Acute appendicitis was diagnosed in 2860 (44.3%) and 3173 (49.2%) of the PS and GS cohorts, respectively, P = 0.008. PS compared to GS performed a higher percentage of laparoscopic (n = 2,697, 89.4% versus n = 2,178, 65.5%) than open appendectomies (n = 280, 9.3% versus n = 1,118, 33.6%), P < 0.001. The overall hospital charges were $28,081 (IQR: $21,706-$37,431) and $24,322 (IQR: $17,906-$32,226) for PS and GS, respectively, P < 0.001. Surgical charges where higher for PS than GS, $12,566 (IQR: $9802-$17,462) and $8051 (IQR: $5872-$2331), respectively. When controlling for diagnosis, surgical approach, emergent status, age, and surgical cost of appendiceal surgery, and hospital charges following appendiceal surgery were $4280 higher for PS than GS (95% CI: 3874-4687). ConclusionsThe total charge for operations for appendiceal disease is significantly higher for PS compared to GS. Pediatric surgeons had increased surgical charges compared to GS but decreased radiology charges. The specific reasons for these differences are not clearly delineated in this data set and persist after controlling for relevant covariates. However, these data demonstrate that increasing value in pediatric appendicitis may require specialty-based targets.