Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using hamstring autograft in over-40 patients. Does preoperative arthritic changes matter?

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of osteoarthritis on the outcome of arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, and to assess the effect of the procedure on the progression of osteoarthritis. Forty-two patients, age above 40, presenting by symptomatic instability secondary to rupture of the ACL were enrolled in a prospective cohort study. Cases were divided into two groups according to the absence of osteoarthritic changes (group I, 19 patients) or presence of osteoarthritic changes (group II, 23 patients) in preoperative radiographs. ACL anatomic single bundle reconstruction by the anteromedial portal technique using hamstring autograft fixed by biodegradable interference fit screws was done for all patients, and a fixed postoperative rehabilitation protocol was applied. Data were recorded and statistical analysis of the preoperative, 1 year follow up, and final follow up (average 41 months in group I and 42 months in group II) results of both groups was conducted. The average patient age at the time of operation was 44.5 years in group I versus 46.4 years in group II. The follow-up median pain scores, ROM, modified Lysholm scores were significantly better in group I compared to group II. On the contrary, the difference between preoperative and 1 year postoperative scores and the percentage of improvement of the modified Lysholm score were significantly higher in group II. Deterioration of the radiographic grade of osteoarthritis in the final follow-up was declared in 15.8 % of patients of group I and in 21.7 % of patients of group II (P = 0.71). Age, concomitant meniscus injury, and presence of preoperative arthritic changes, and cartilage defect had no statistically significantly effect on the success rate. Patients who had ACL reconstruction more than 2 years after injury and those with higher body mass index (BMI) had worse outcome than those who had earlier reconstruction and lower BMI. Patients having preoperative mild to moderate arthritic changes will indeed benefit from ACL reconstruction at short term, although their overall functional outcome seemed to be inferior to the outcome of non-arthritic patients. However, osteoarthritic changes deteriorate over time in both groups especially when there is preoperative mild to moderate arthritic changes.