Abstract
The paper analyzes the legal institution of administrative quasi-judicial bodies in the Anglo-Saxon and continental European legal families. In general, administrative quasi-judicial bodies refer to bodies created by the state (the legislature or, as in the US, the president) for the purpose of regulating certain critical areas of activity (the economy and human rights), as well as for settling disputes out of court, when the state does not consider itself legitimate to intervene directly. For ideological reasons, this institution is more developed in the AngloSaxon countries, in which the mechanisms of deregulation, or the phenomenon of deetatization, are the norm of government. In the countries of the European-continental model, the state played a decisive role for a long time, which is why the spread of this institution began later and was carried out more slowly, mainly after the Second World War, when the state was discredited ideologically in favor of civil society. The relevance of these bodies to the state continues to give rise to many doctrinal disputes, especially in the context of their independence. The independence of quasi-judicial administrative bodies does not mean that they are irresponsible and that the state that creates them has no obligations. Moreover, all legal principles and guarantees of the independence and impartiality of justice are applied in the performance of judicial functions by these bodies. Here there is an ideological impasse: attempts to alienate justice from the state through the establishment of para-state judicial bodies will result either in their politicization or in their return to the public sphere.
Highlights
The paper analyzes the legal institution of administrative quasi-judicial bodies in the Anglo-Saxon and continental European legal families
Administrative quasi-judicial bodies refer to bodies created by the state for the purpose of regulating certain critical areas of activity, as well as for settling disputes out of court, when the state does not consider itself legitimate to intervene directly
This institution is more developed in the AngloSaxon countries, in which the mechanisms of deregulation, or the phenomenon of deetatization, are the norm of government
Summary
Федеральная комиссия по торговле (Federal Trade Commission), в 1934 г. В некоторых случаях полномочия этих органов усилены, и они сами могут принимать нормативные акты (более или менее общего значения) в рамках закона. В странах европейско-континентальной модели также имеются административные квазисудебные органы, у которых имеются репрессивные полномочия, а иногда и полномочие принимать решение. Вопрос заключается в определении зависимости и (или) независимости этих административных квазисудебных органов от судебных структур расследования. В процессе создания административных квазисудебных органов невозможно не учитывать политический фактор, в том числе политическую борьбу между органами исполнительной и законодательной власти, а также их ситуативные политические интересы. 19 «Considérant que le principe de la séparation des pouvoirs fait obstacle à ce que, en l’absence de disposition constitutionnelle le permettant, le pouvoir de nomination par une autorité administrative ou juridictionnelle квазисудебных органов, а также создавать парламентские комиссии, президент вправе прекращать полномочия руководителей, законодатель может прекращать существование этих структур No 658-DC (п. 39). 19 «Considérant que le principe de la séparation des pouvoirs fait obstacle à ce que, en l’absence de disposition constitutionnelle le permettant, le pouvoir de nomination par une autorité administrative ou juridictionnelle квазисудебных органов, а также создавать парламентские комиссии, президент вправе прекращать полномочия руководителей, законодатель может прекращать существование этих структур
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.