Addressing the commercial determinants of mental health: an umbrella review of population-level interventions.

Abstract

There is increasing evidence that commercial determinants impact mental health. Addressing the commercial determinants may therefore be a way of improving population-level mental health. This umbrella review aimed to provide an overview of evidence in this field and identify knowledge gaps. Five databases (MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO, Scopus and Cochrane Library) were searched on the 18/19 of July 2022. Eligible papers were systematic reviews published after 31 December 2011. No geographical limits were applied. Eligible interventions were those that targeted the behaviours or products of commercial actors. Ineligible interventions included individual behaviour change interventions, such as those seeking to educate consumers. Included mental health outcomes were anxiety, depression, self-harm and suicide, whilst surrogate outcomes included product consumption. Industry involvement and the quality of included reviews (critical components of A MeaSurementTool toAssess systematicReviews -AMSTAR 2) were assessed. A narrative synthesis was used to compare the findings by industry, and a typology of interventions was developed. Eight reviews with mental health outcomes were included, each with multiple methodological weaknesses. There is some evidence that reducing the availability of alcohol or pesticides may lower suicide rates. Despite the known links, no evidence on the mental health impacts of population-level interventions tackling the social media, tobacco, gambling and ultra-processed foods industries were located. All gambling reviews were identified as having links to industry. Future high-quality evaluations of commercial determinants interventions developed specifically with the aim of achieving positive mental health outcomes and/or that evaluate mental health outcomes and are free from industry links are needed. PROSPERO ref. number CRD42022346002.