A qualitative case study of health system barriers and facilitators to living donor kidney transplantation in Canada's most populous province

Abstract

AbstractPatients with kidney failure need dialysis or a kidney transplant to survive. Living donor kidney transplantation (LDKT) is the best therapeutic option, yet global rates of LDKT have minimally increased, and there are disparities in access. The need for a systems approach to improvement has been highlighted. We aimed to understand what elements of a relatively large health system interact to deliver LDKT and act as facilitators or barriers. This was an exploratory case study of Ontario, the most populous province in Canada that conducts 600–700 kidney transplantations annually, of which ~30% are LDKT. Data collection entailed interviews with multiple stakeholders (n = 37), and document review (n = 29) served as a means of triangulating the data. Data were analyzed using inductive thematic analysis. A multicomponent intervention to facilitate kidney transplantation was simultaneously being conducted which allowed us to capture its impact (EnAKT‐LKD). Eight themes were identified, that were separated into facilitators and barriers. Centralized leadership, directed resource deployment, dynamic communities of practice, and informal collaborations between various elements of the health system were found to facilitate LDKT. Barriers were inadequate donor and patient resources to support equitable access, lengthy and poorly coordinated workups for donors and recipients, and issues of jurisdictional control and competition for resources. The EnAKT‐LKD initiative was described as having boosted resource deployment and collaborative capacity and improved strategic alliances by establishing communities of practice. This case study has identified how individual elements in a health system interact to facilitate and impede the delivery of a therapy to patients.