A comparison of three-film analysis software for stereotactic radiotherapy patient-specific quality assurance.

Abstract

The aim of this study was to investigate the suitability of three radiochromic film analysis software for stereotactic radiotherapy patient-specific quality assurance (PSQA): FilmQA Pro v5.0, SNC Patient v6.2, and eFilmQA v5.0. Film calibration was conducted for each software followed by three sets of measurements. The first set assessed calibration accuracy by comparing measured and delivered doses at increments different from those used for calibration. The second set used each software to conduct PSQA through gamma analysis on 10 stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) and stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) patients. The third set utilized SNC Patient and eFilmQA to carry out gamma analysis on a collection of four digital test images, eliminating delivery and scanning uncertainties from impacting the analysis. Key supporting features within each software for conducting gamma analysis were identified. Overall, FilmQA Pro and eFilmQA were deemed comparable and favoured over SNC Patient due to the presence of key features such as triple-channel dosimetry, auto-optimization, and dose scaling. FilmQA Pro has a substantial user base and established reputation. eFilmQA, having been introduced more recently, serves as a viable alternative to FilmQA Pro, having been further refined for stereotactic radiotherapy PSQA. This study investigated the suitability of three film analysis software (FilmQA Pro, eFilmQA, and SNC Patient) for stereotactic radiotherapy PSQA. Results from the investigation indicated that both FilmQA Pro and eFilmQA are comparably suitable and are preferred over SNC Patient. Both FilmQA Pro and eFilmQA are recommended for radiotherapy clinics.